O Sole Mio NY

2194 Nesconset Hwy, Stony Brook, NY 11790, United States
+1 631-751-1600
$$$ Pizza restaurant
(1481 Reviews)
Price Range $20–30

O Sole Mio NY is a straightforward Italian pizza spot tucked into a busy strip mall on Nesconset Highway in Stony Brook. The feel is casual and lively, especially around lunch and dinner hours when the place tends to fill up with locals looking for solid Italian comfort food without pretense. Expect a bustling dining room where the chatter and clatter of dishes reflect a neighborhood favorite rather than an upscale dining experience.

The menu leans heavily into classic Italian-American pizzas and pasta dishes, with a few seafood options that stand out, like the broiled flounder and shrimp scampi. Among the pizza selections, the “Grandpa” square slice and the “Grandma” slice offer different takes on thin, crisp crusts that hit that perfect combo of crunchy with a fresh, well-balanced topping layer. There’s also a variety of sides like garlic knots and baked clams that help round out a meal.

Service here moves quickly despite the rush, showing a rhythm that fits a place used to busy peak times. Staffers tend to be friendly and efficient, which helps keep things running smoothly when it gets crowded. The atmosphere is straightforward Italian-American casual—there’s a buzz that’s lively but not overly noisy, though the choice of background music sometimes leans away from the usual Italian staples and might be a bit louder than some expect.

This spot suits anyone after a no-frills, hearty meal—whether grabbing a slice at lunch or settling in for a full dinner. Families, local workers, and longtime customers seem to appreciate the generous portions and classic flavors. Those who prioritize authenticity and atmosphere might miss a bit of that old-world charm, but if you’re after solid pizza and classic dishes with quick service in a familiar, neighborhood setting, this is a reliable choice on the North Shore.

Highlights
Has fast service
Serves great cocktails
Serves great dessert
Has great wine list
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
What they serve
Serves alcohol
Serves beer
Serves cocktails
Serves coffee
Serves comfort food
Serves healthy options
Serves late-night food
Quick bite
Serves small plates
Serves spirits
Serves vegetarian dishes
Serves wine
Best for
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Has catering
Serves dessert
Has seating
Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
On-site parking
Plenty of parking

Openings Hours

Checking

Monday

11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Tuesday

11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Wednesday

11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Thursday

11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Friday

11:00 AM - 11:00 PM

Saturday

11:00 AM - 11:00 PM

Sunday

11:00 AM - 10:00 PM

1481 Reviews
andrew bromm

27 Dec 2025

Busy Italian restaurant featuring a Wide variety of Pizza, pasta, and a wide variety of classic Italian dishes Food was fresh, hot, attractively presented, and the portions were generous. What most impressed me about this place was the service. Coming from the world of fine dining, I pay more attention to service mechanics than most. The restaurant was full and I didn’t have a reservation, however was seated after a short wait. Service was prompt, cordial, interactive, knowledgeable, and well timed. I was especially impressed by the bus staff. Tables were cleared, sanitized, seats were wiped down, floor underneath the table swept, and the tables were reset typically before the departing customers exited. I’ll be back.

Paul Mallia

10 Dec 2025

Have been coming here for over 20 years. One of the best Italian restaurants and pizza places in the area. The atmosphere, service, and staff are great. Love the food dishes equally as much as the pizza. Highly recommend!

Nicholas Gkionis

04 Dec 2025

Neighborhood pizzeria’s are my jam. This one is in a strip mall but was busy for lunch so it must be good. The grandpa square was lovely. The thin square also had a crunch to hit that was hard not to like. They have all sorts of specialty sliced as well. The dining room was busy for lunch which is a good sign. I would for sure come back for a slice.

Tai Vicari

10 Nov 2025

It's a really busy place. The service was fast and friendly. The pizza was good. The utensils and napkins were cheap. For the volume and pricing, they can afford to take up the quality a notch. The music was a bit loud and not Italian. Not that it has to be but most Italian restaurants either play Italian music or classical opera. If you need a slice of $4.25 pizza this is your spot.

Willie Ruiz

23 Sep 2025

Great pizza and good service even as we came in late and near closing. Pizzas came out quickly once ordered.

Grace Hyeri Chung Ji

16 Sep 2025

Excellent food and service! The food was amazing. The salad, pizza and the pasta were all delicious. The portion size runs generally large. I highly recommend this place for a small family or friends gathering. This is a cozy area. The area might be tight to mobile.

9M Cafe

9M Cafe

M457+6PJ, Unnamed Road, السيب‎،, Seeb, Muscat, Oman
Coffee shop
(29 Reviews)
Caffe Amici - NY 11784

Caffe Amici - NY 11784

353 Independence Plaza, Selden, NY 11784, United States
Restaurant
(1438 Reviews)
Wing Sing Dim Sum

Wing Sing Dim Sum

1125 Stockton St, San Francisco, CA 94133, United States
Dim sum restaurant
(228 Reviews)
Presso Cafe & Lounge

Presso Cafe & Lounge

Alt-Müggelheim 1A, 12559 Berlin, Germany
Cafe
(61 Reviews)
Frontier Wok Too

Frontier Wok Too

1816 W Olive Ave, Burbank, CA 91506, United States
Chinese restaurant
(565 Reviews)

Join the O Sole Mio NY Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.